— King's College London
"With an exceptional knowledge both of Balthasar's vast corpus and of the burgeoning secondary literature on him, Karen Kilby has given us a highly perceptive and accessible analysis of the influential Swiss theologian's work and legacy. Her book is always fair-minded, but it is also unerringly incisive and tenacious in its argument that Balthasar's project has a 'performative contradiction' at its heart. She is as attentive to his method and habits of mind (where so many of his vulnerabilities lie) as to the explicit content of what he says. By denying Balthasar the status of sacred cow, Kilby ensures that he will remain a much more useful and productive source of nourishment for the next generation of theologians."
David Burrell, C.S.C.
— University of Notre Dame
"Karen Kilby exposes the plotline of Balthasar's formidable opus and proceeds to offer circumspect criticism of the supremely confident modes of expression his speculation can take. With grammar as a critical tool, she inquires trenchantly what might allow this 'theological novelist' to know his divine characters so well as to spin the story he does."
— University of Roehampton
"This book should be essential reading for anybody interested in contemporary Catholicism and its most flamboyant theologian. Kilby approaches her subject with a lucidity and balance that are rare in studies of Hans Urs von Balthasar. While meticulously careful to avoid gratuitous criticism, she offers a timely caution against the uncritical acceptance of Balthasar's work and its influence on much recent theology and doctrine."
Anglican Theological Review
"This book is an astonishingly deft guide to thorny and difficult issues, and a brief, approachable introduction to Catholic theological issues of recent centuries. It is a terrific piece of theological scholarship and critique and will be most appreciated by advanced theology students, clergy and theologians wanting a solid orientation to Balthasar. As simply one of the best introductions to the life, thought, work, contributions, and limitations of Balthasar available today, it is highly recommended."
"In the midst of so much work currently being done on Balthasar, Kilby's (very) critical comments are, in my opinion, much needed signposts along the road toward recovering what is good and worth saving within his oeuvre. There is a great need to strike such a balancing act between critique and recovery in Balthasar's work, and this slim volume contributes greatly toward that highly worthwhile task."
Reviews in Religion & Theology
"Despite its brevity, this book may well take its place as the most essential secondary source on Balthasar's work. What it lacks in comprehensiveness it gains in deep insights into the recurrent patterns of Balthasar's thinking and the influence of his life experience on those patterns."
"This tough-minded yet irenic essay . . . is extraordinarily helpful to those who want to know what the excitement is about — and what the limits to that excitement ought to be."