Christopher J. Insole
— in Times Literary Supplement
"The Ways of Judgment is political theology as it used to be done, and as it should not be attempted at home. In a no-nonsense way, we are simply told what certain concepts mean, and instructed in what the proper shape of political order ought to be. All this without extensive qualification, justification, commentary on the literature, or academic caution. . . It is meant as a high compliment to say that The Ways of Judgment is a deeply and astonishingly unfashionable book. . . A glory of this book is that everyone — liberals, conservatives, communitarians, socialists, libertarians — will likely be offended by something."
"This rewarding but difficult book makes a significant contribution to the neglected discipline of political theology. Recommended."
William C. Placher
— in The Christian Century
"No one should accuse Oliver O'Donovan of tackling easy topics. . . In rich dialogue with both political thinkers and the Christian tradition, O'Donovan addresses many of the traditional topics of a course in political theory: justice, equality, authority, legitimacy, and so on. . . At every stage, O'Donovan offers challenging conclusions."
— Yale University
"In this sequel to his Desire of the Nations, Oliver O'Donovan displays a wisdom we have come to expect from him. He throws light on political conceptions from the final vantage point of Christian convictions resident in the creeds. A powerful, carefully considered work that unforgettably reconceives how we may live in late-modern Western society."
— University of Notre Dame
"This book merits comparison with Reinhold Niebuhr's Nature and Destiny of Man, and I expect it to be a benchmark for political theology for many years to come."
James V. Schall, S.J.
"Oliver O'Donovan presents us here with a thorough and reflective book on the essence of politics and its institutions. This is not merely another political science book, however, but an intellectual history of the very theological and philosophical ideas out of which our modern political rhetoric grew, including that system that sought to understand itself without revelation. Chesterton once remarked that the very purpose of the mind is ultimately “to judge; in many ways, O'Donovan rightly says, politics is a continual act of judgment, an effort to distinguish what is right from what is wrong. O'Donovan carefully shows us what this means in the realm of politics and what are its transcendent implications."
"An important and serious work by a mature scholar who asks questions that are fundamental to any reflective Christian trying to do right by love of Christ and country."
Theological Book Review
"O'Donovan's writing is elegant, eloquent, and subtle; it is erudite, yet accessible. . . Every chapter is marked by wisdom, where a concern for the truth and ideals is tempered by realism and expression."
"If you want to think seriously and hard as a Christian about what politics is, and if you're exhausted and depressed by the harsh and shrill station-identification that passes for political discourse in the imperial America of this new millennium, you should read this book."
Rev. Lord Habgood in Church Times
"A weighty and demanding book that needs and deserves concentrated attention. It is packed with controversial ideas and sharp judgments concerning the nature of politics and government."